Slate: "How to Buck Up the Science Ladies"

Article here. Excerpt:

'Last week, researchers at the University of Colorado published a psych experiment that seems almost too good to be true. They showed that two 15-minute writing exercises, administered to an intro physics class early in the semester, could substantially boost the scores of female students. Even more curious: the exercises had nothing to do with physics. Instead, students were asked to write about things that mattered to them, like creativity or relationships with family and friends. How could a few paragraphs on personal values translate into enduring better mastery of pulleys and frictionless planes?
...
...Stereotype threat is a universal offender: It can sabotage white men on the basketball court or men more broadly on a test of social sensitivity. Whenever people are made to worry that they might confirm a negative assumption—for instance, that girls can't do math or that white men can't jump—they may be less likely to do their best. Frustratingly, the stereotypes they want so badly to avoid instead may instead become self-fulfilling....
...

Of course, stereotype threat isn't the only reason that women remain underrepresented in math and science. Previously, some of the co-authors of the new study found that differences in background explained 60 percent of the disparity between their male and female students' physics scores, with the men more likely to have taken physics in high school. After giving the affirming writing exercises, the researchers did another analysis that controlled for differences in prior math scores, which correlated with who'd done more or less past math and physics coursework. This time, they found no statistically significant gender disparities in the scores for the standardized physics test or other physics exams.'

Like0 Dislike0

Comments

Where's the study on how men are effected or succumb to the stereotype threat of being called rapists, murderers, wife-beaters and deadbeat dads all the time?

Like0 Dislike0

Homo Sapiens has the highest ratio of brain mass to body mass among all living creatures. Do feminists think that the size of brain doesn't matter? =))

----------------------------------------------------
Single men is the only social group benefited from feminism.

Like0 Dislike0

'do feminists think...?

answer: no.

Like0 Dislike0

Well said

Like0 Dislike0

From what I see the study doesn't imply anything about stereotype threat; it merely improved the scores of women. You could just as well have improved the scores of men by playing football, write on Beowulf, or anything else that stimulates and gives them a better impression of the class.

They also picked an into physics class which means many people aren't very interested in the first place. They should have at least studied students in higher physics who are already committed.

From the article "(There was no effect for women who were getting A's, or for men in general.)"

Even in an entry level class the study had no effect on the better female students.

Like0 Dislike0