The #MeToo Movement has thrown due process out the window

Letter here.

'In her recent letter to the Tribune (“A witch hunt”), writer Dorie Chaille Tiseth hit the nail on the head. I, too, have been shocked by the rapidity and fury with which the #MeToo movement has swirled across the country, upending lives and leaving us stunned.

Like that writer, I am in my 70s and a feminist, and as a woman, I have encountered and witnessed decades of sexual harassment. I am therefore not denying the premise that such conduct is insufferable and ought to be punished. However, as a retired public defender, I have seen more than my share of shaded motivations on both sides of sexual issues. I remember more than a few juries where criminal accusations by “girlfriends” against males were heard and defendants ultimately exonerated. Other juries have found defendants guilty. In any case, however, these juries heard testimony, saw evidence, evaluated arguments, and had the opportunity to figure out what the facts were before applying the law and coming to a verdict of guilt or innocence. That is called due process.

In contrast, in our current circus atmosphere of media coverage, there is no such thing as due process. Non-legal charges are broadcast against persons, often beyond a statute of limitations, with little, if any, discernible attempts to corroborate the charges before they are made public. Then rapidly these persons, usually male, are not only pronounced guilty by public opinion, but they are either quickly fired from their jobs or they resign into oblivion.

In other words, the concept of due process has been thrown out the window. Surely there is a better way to redress or prevent grievances of such magnitude and seriousness, is there not? That is the question many are now asking, and I hope it is not answered with the crumbling of the rule of law.

— Jeanine Tobin, Chicago'

up
32 users have voted.
I like this

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

By one reckoning, 98 is the total

97 men, 1 woman. But I think the number's low. The author writes about how good all this is. No doubt some no. of these people should be "toppled", as their behavior did or does rise to the criminal or the so-outrageous as to be intolerable. But all 98? Without a hearing and review of facts, how can anyone be reasonably certain? As MANN has repeatedly shown, yes Virginia, there are indeed women who lie about things like sexual assault, harassment, etc., for whatever reasons. #MeToo refuses to acknowledge this fact.

Most victims of the Salem Witch Trials were men, executed with ropes around their necks. Only thing missing in this case is the ropes and an actual trial. Well, stay tuned. No one like HRC or K. Gillibrand has moved into the Oval Office -- yet.

https://www.thedailybeast.com/the-97-men-and-one-woman-taken-down-by-the-metoo-movement

up
2 users have voted.
I like this