[an error occurred while processing this directive]
"Date-Rape" Down at UNH, And Men Can Be Victims Too
posted by Scott on Thursday June 21, @11:09AM
from the education dept.
Education Nightmist writes "In this story on Excite News, Dr. Ellen S. Cohn of the University of New Hampshire says that incidents of date rape and nonconsensual sexual contact are on a decline on that campus. The most interesting part of this study, however, is at the end of the article, where Cohn admits that 8 percent of men in the study reported unwanted sexual contact and 4 percent reported unwanted intercourse. Said Cohn: "I think that people for the most part have associated victims with being women. But in fact we know that there are cases of men who are victims, as well. I think it's just harder for men to come forward and admit that they've been victims.""

White Men Downsized at Ford Motor Co. | Two Points for More Responsible Rape Prosecutions  >

  
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Still clinging to the broad definition of rape (Score:2)
by frank h on Thursday June 21, @12:20PM EST (#1)
(User #141 Info)
Cohn states in the eighth paragraph of this article that "While these numbers remain unacceptable, Cohn is encouraged that rates of sexual assault are in decline..." I infer from this that she applies the Dworking definition of rape, that ANY unwanted sexual contact constitutes rape, or at least sexual assault. With this broad definition, her numbers could be regarded as supporting the feminist claim of "1 in 4." While I do applaud her final statement, I still find research like this to be specious because of the broad defintion of sexual assault. I suggest we question this study further.
Re:Still clinging to the broad definition of rape (Score:0)
by Anonymous User on Thursday June 21, @03:00PM EST (#2)

I think that you should scrutinize this article a bit more closely. This article clearly states that "The researchers defined unwanted sexual contact as situations in which individuals tried to rebuff a sexual advance by saying words like "no" or by physically struggling or crying, or situations in which sexual contact occurred under threat of violence or with the victim being drugged or passed out."

Although this sort of thing has been misrepresented as rape in the past, and no doubt will be again in the future, I don't see from this article that she is trying to do that. Just because something isn't rape doesn't mean that it isn't worth measuring or studying.

Further down we get a clearer picture of where the rape comes in. "while 6.4% [of the women interviewed] said the unwanted contact had included intercourse." So it would seem from this study that she didn't work with the assumption that "ANY unwanted sexual contact constitutes rape".

This study certainly can't be taken at face value though, particularly considering that her rate of 6.4% covers one semester! That very roughly works out to over 12% per year (not counting summer) which puts the "1 in 4" figure (which is over a college carreer and includes both completed and attempted rapes) to shame.(The US NIJ has a lifetime rate of rape around 7-8%)

Her methodology certainly needs some looking into, furthermore Reuters deserves a slap on the wrist for not mentioning that all her numbers are well out of the norm even for a feminist study.


Re:Still clinging to the broad definition of rape (Score:2)
by frank h on Friday June 22, @09:40AM EST (#3)
(User #141 Info)
At the suggestion of Anonymous User, I did go back and re-read the article and I stand by my assertion. This article reads as though any unwanted sexual contact is defined as "sexual assault." Consider a couple who have been dating for a number weeks and who have an established pattern of sexual activity. If one makes a polite advance and it is subsequently rebuffed without anger, it still becomes "sexual assault."
Re:Still clinging to the broad definition of rape (Score:2)
by frank h on Wednesday June 27, @04:10PM EST (#4)
(User #141 Info)
I stand corrected. Ms. Cohn advised me that the definition she uses of "sexual assault" does not include cases where polite overtures are made among familiar partners and subsequently, also politely, rebuffed.
[an error occurred while processing this directive]